Peter: It Is Your Call!

I am not political but it is time that they settled this water fragmentation mess left over from the former government of Selangor. Many hidden hands were involved but that is history and the people wants to know when they can get clean water and to ensure that the water subsidy scheme remains in place.

The person everyone is looking at for a solution is Peter Chin, the Federal Minister of Water. What ever happened to the restructuring exercise?

Let us look at some of the salient points involved here.

The Selangor people wants the best solution. They want the best deal. They are hoping that with the powers vested in him viz the Water Services Industry Act (WSIA), he may work out something good.

“Section 114 of WSIA, if invoked, gives the minister the power to force the water players to hand over the assets in the name of national interest.”

So far there have been three offers. Let us look at them at close range.

i.  The Selangor government’s offer to restructure the state’s water industry.

Apparently it is fair to all water concessionaires as well as benefit the rakyat guaranteeing  no tariff increases for the foreseeable future. This is structured in such a manner due to the lower proposed leasing cost by the state government from PAAB of approximately five per cent. Compare this with Gamuda’s cost of six per cent.

Further cost savings can be realised by “the lower cost of acquiring all assets of water concessionaires”, previously estimated at between RM9.2 billion and RM10.3 billion.

The State Government acquisition is based on the principle and philosophy of not  seeking to “maximise profits but instead maximise returns” to the public. Compare this to Gamuda Bhd's offer that will instead guarantee equity returns in excess of 10 per cent per annum.

This offer  was the attempt by the  Selangor government, via its investment arm Kumpulan Darul Ehsan Bhd, to  take over the restructuring  of the water industry thereby fulfilling  its promise to provide cheaper water to its electorate.

The state’s offer of RM9.2 billion was accepted by water concessionaires, Konsortium ABASS and Splash, but was rejected by Syabas and Puncak Niaga Sdn Bhd (PNSB).

ii. The Federal Government Bid

Done through its Water Asset Management Company (PAAB). It made an “informal” offer to acquire all assets from the water concessionaires amounting to RM10.3 billion in March 2010.However, the offer was rejected by water concessionaires, Abass and Splash, while both Syabas and Puncak Niaga Sdn Bhd (PNSB) have missed the April 6 deadline to repond.

“The deal by the Selangor state government is the best there is for the rakyat as we have affirmed no tariff increases for the foreseeable future. This can be achieved due to the lower proposed leasing cost by the state government from PAAB of approximately five per cent, compared to Gamuda’s cost of six per cent.
Pua added that further cost savings would be realised by “the lower cost of acquiring all assets of water concessionaires”, which was previously estimated at between RM9.2 billion and RM10.3 billion.
He added that the state government was not seeking to “maximise profits but instead maximise returns” to the public. Gamuda Bhd has confirmed their offer will guarantee equity returns in excess of 10 per cent per annum.


iii. Gamuda also made a revised offer yesterday to acquire all of the state’s water concessionaires through its associate, Splash, and this would cost the conglomerate RM10.75 billion. This is the best in terms of the valuation of the water concessionaires, being the highest offer on the table. They have promised to freeze water tariff increase in the first year and increase only between 2-3 per cent annually for subsequent years.

The Pahang-Selangor  Water Transfer Project has already started a month back and yet we see a lack of will among politicians to resolve the problem of the restructuring of water concessionaires.

Who are we waiting for? Godot?

We must be a first world nation with a third world mentality.