October 16, 2009

What can Go Wrong with this Equity Rally.

For those dabbling in equities, a Reuters report suggest a look out for four potential bugbears.

Read the report from London circa October 16.

Four major risks threaten a solid year-end rally to cap this year’s stunning bounce back by global equities — earnings, bonds, currencies and cash.

Investor optimism has been so unrestrained recently that good earnings are beginning to be dismissed because they do not meet exaggerated expectations.

Take Goldman Sachs this week, for example. It beat earnings expectations by 23 per cent on a per share basis but the announcement was met with disappointment.

Stocks fell and the dollar rose initially when the results came out because the market was so ebullient it was willing to believe a so-called “whisper number” for the earnings at the wildest edge of speculation.

In the event, stocks recovered to close higher on the day. But disappointments were the order of the day today.

Nonetheless, world stocks begin next week at 12-month highs, up well over 70 per cent from their March lows. High-yielding currencies are in huge demand and emerging market debt spreads have narrowed about half a percentage point in October alone.

Underlining it all, measures of the volatility of Wall Street stocks are falling. The VIX volatililty index, the “fear gauge”, has broken below its recent range and is now at “normal”, pre-crisis levels.

That in itself automatically creates buy signals in many trading models.

This all points to risk-hungry investors entering a new week with the bit between their teeth again, despite the odd disappointment such as Friday’s Bank of America loss.

“Earnings turned in the second quarter of this year. We are on track for a good 18 months of corporate earnings growth,” said Bob Parker, vice chairman of Credit Suisse’s asset management arm.

The market is enjoying high levels of liquidity, a store of investor cash and generally positive economic numbers, he said.

Underlying economic numbers such as Chinese trade and lending, UK unemployment, US retail sales and euro zone manufacturing have come in better than expected.

Reuters polls this week found expectations among economists that the US and euro zone economies came out of recession in the third quarter.

There are, nonetheless, the four risks. Much of the latest tranche of the stock rally is based on optimism over earnings.

Notwithstanding Goldman’s failure to meet excessive expectations and the Bank of America results, many reports have been positive, among them JPMorgan Chase, Google and IBM.

Thomson Reuters Proprietary Research shows that as of Thursday, with 10 per cent of S&P 500 index companies having reported, 82 percent had beaten expectations.

Should many others come in below forecast or expectations rise too high Goldman-like, the market would be vulnerable to a quick reversal.

Retailers will be in focus next week and Europe will have its first full week of reporting. Results are due from Apple, Nestle, Danone, Coca-Cola, Cadbury, Hershey, LVMH, PPR, Ahold and Home Retail.

Government bond yields, in the meantime, have been rising modestly this month as equities have gained and risk appetite built up. The risk is that this becomes more rapid, creating a sell-off that would send borrowing rates through the roof.

The factors mitigating against this are continued low rates and quantitative easing from central banks along with muted inflationary pressures.

This leaves markets highly sensitive to any hint that authorities are seeking to exit from the programmes the set in place to combat the financial crisis. Australia, for example, has already begun raising rates.

All eyes next week will also be on the currency markets where the dollar’s overall decline has begun to concern those countries whose currencies are rising as a result.

“If we have dollar/euro going to US$1.60 (RM5.40) very quickly that would put a big constraint on euro zone economic recovery, likewise the yen at 85,” Credit Suisse’s Parker said.

The dollar was a fair way from these levels today, at around US$1.49 to the euro and 91 yen -- but the fact that these levels are being mentioned shows the sentiment towards the dollar.

It has fallen 6.6 per cent against a basket of major currencies this year.

Parity, meanwhile, is drawing nearer for the US dollar/Canadian dollar, dollar/Swiss franc and euro/sterling. The psychological impact of hitting such rates would magnify the official reaction, exporters’ scramble to hedge, and the complaints about loss of competitive advantage.

Finally, there are signs that the tidal wave of cash that was put into money market funds at the height of the financial crisis has now mostly been thrown back into other assets this year.

“The latest outflows from money market funds took the YTD total to US$396 billion, equal to nearly 94 per cent of the total weekly inflows recorded by this fund group during 2008,” Fund trackers EPFR Global said this week."

MCA: The Sounds of Silence

The reason for the deafening silence is only known to the beleaguered President. Against all odds,he chose silence to be his defense. To the CC's disgust and consternation,the once gung-ho President then used the remaining ace in his sleeve to call for yet another EGM.

Has he studied the ramifications of this move? Was he clutching at straws in an attempt to extend his lease of political life at MCA? Was it the best move to salvage MCA for its own sake? Only Ong knows.

The conflict against Ong this time was closer home. Departing from the heated Lee San Choon Hall on the faithful day of 10th October where he lost in a no-confidence vote,the action stations have now shifted to the President's own backyard- The CC and the Presidential Council.

Even here, he has lost ground. No one can confirm it at this juncture , but more than 20 of the 42 members wanted him to go. It was a heated CC session debate. Nonetheless, it ended up with nothing to show for.

In an apparent defense, back from the CC Meeting, Ong quickly pre-empted everyone by stating in his blog that Dr Chua Soi Lek's blatant sacking was made collectively by both the the Central Committee and the Presidential Council. As such all members of both CC and Presidential Council must take full responsibility too.

Under MCA’s constitution, a party president can only be removed by a vote from at least two-thirds of national delegates at an EGM. And Ong knew this.

Yesterday, Secretary-General Wong Foon Meng said the new EGM will have only one resolution, which is to support the president and to remove the entire central committee. The legal implications of such a resolution are still being debated.

And so until the new EGM takes place,MCA will be double boiling like stewed bah kut teh . Will the soup still taste bitter?

Morally or Constitutionally-Which Holds Sway?

More information has now leaked out about what actually transpired on the afternoon of 15th October at the MCA CC Meeting. It is now common fact that President Ong had refused to quit despite a majority of CC members requesting his resignation.

Ong then used his prerogative as President after that meeting to call for yet another EGM.

So what will be the issue that will have to be decided by delegates at this new EGM?

According to Secretary-General Wong Foon Meng, delegates will be asked to either support Ong or to dissolve the central committee so that fresh elections can be held.

The wording of the resolution proposed for the next EGM is thus very important. No one wants what happened on Double Ten to rear its ugly head again. Because the MCA constitution is supreme, Ong cannot be dislodged legally and so gets to keep his seat even though he has lost all moral rights to it.

The only way to unseat him, if he refused to resign, is to have two third of the Central committee resigned immediately, thereby precipitating fresh elections.Until that happens, Ong gets to continue as President and also be by extension, a Cabinet minister.

Interestingly, by having this new EGM, Ong get a second bite at the cherry by asking the same delegates who gave him a vote of no confidence last weekend to now back his leadership.

His current action has now pitted him squarely against the erstwhile central committee members and their supporters who supported him at the earlier EGM. So, just looking at the potential numbers lined up against him, expect Ong , in all likelihood,to lose the vote again.

Until the next EGM day arrives, rival factions will surely be working overtime to develop strategies and counter strategies to secure their vested interests.

And so, at this sad nadir of MCA's long history, also anticipate that narrow and naked 'Me, Mine and Myself' objective to drive both the challengers and the incumbents as they go forth on their quest for party ascension and self-preservation.

As observers, we now await with baited breath on what will transpire next in this unfolding chinese wayang.